IdeaConnection.com 
Access Teams of Expert Solvers led by World-Class Facilitators
Login | Register
Search Solutions:

Excessive influence of pharmaceutical manufacturers over doctors

Post a Problem
Education and advertising campaigns have raised concerns that pharmaceutical companies, traditionally in the business of finding new drugs for existing disorders, are increasingly in the businesses of promoting their own brands on non-medical grounds and, even more unethically, seeking new disorders for existing drugs. For example, some drug marketing seems to imply that huge proportions of the population need pharmaceutical intervention for relatively common problems, and for which medication is of dubious benefit

Doctors have become inextricably tied up with the pharmaceutical industry. Their education comes from information supplied by the manufacturers, along with gifts, which some may come to view as a necessary supplement to their salaries. Theoretically, doctors are independent professionals and are trained to assess the value of new drugs when they appear on the market. In practice, most doctors simply prescribe what they are told to by the drug companies, because so many of the medicines now available have appeared since doctors completed their medical training. With an estimated 30,000 drugs being produced, not even the most assiduous expert can hope to keep up to date with what is available. This means that the responsibility for ensuring that new drugs are safe, and that doctors are warned of new side effects when they appear, lies largely with the industry itself. More than 90 percent of the information which doctors receive about drugs comes partly or entirely from the drug manufacturers. Most of the world's 30,000 medical journals are financed by advertisements from the drug industry

Certain drugs may be treated in in current discussion as if they are obsolete, whereas they can have a great deal of clinical utility, particularly as augmenting medications. The best example of this phenomenon is lithium, an important and proven drug for bipolar disorder. No company is marketing it presently, and there is aggressive marketing of other medications for bipolar disorder. As a result, a lot of clinicians are becoming convinced that lithium is an inferior drug. This kind of marketing has almost relegated a useful medication to the status of historical artifact

During the period 1990-2000, a comprehensive media campaign was coordinated by a New York public relations agency working for for the pharmaceutical company that manufactures the anti-depressant Paxil. The campaign delivered communications and testimonials from advocates and doctors who claimed that more than 10 million Americans suffered from social anxiety disorder- a debilitating form of bashfulness - making it the most common mental disorder after depression and alcoholism - and that 13 percent of Americans were affected by it. (According to the National Institute of Mental Health says only about 3.7 percent of the US population has social anxiety disorder. Prior to this time, social anxiety disorder had been mentioned only 50 times in the medical literature.) Around 96 per cent of the stories delivered the key message that the drug Paxil was the first and only FDA-approved medication for the treatment of social anxiety disorder. Sales of Paxil, which had been trailing those of Prozac and Zoloft, rose 18 percent in 2000. The campaign mentioned a psychological therapy called cognitive behaviour therapy, but did not stress that the therapy was as effective as medication, had no side effects and did not require patients to stay in treatment indefinitely

Pharmaceutical companies which are marketing psychopharmacological treatments shifted into the business of selling psychiatric illness. If you are the only manufacturer who has the drug for a specific condition, it is in your interest to broaden the category as far as possible and make the borders as fuzzy as possible. Blurring the line between normal personality variation and real psychiatric conditions can medicalizing normative things and trivialize serious mental illness

1. Every marketer's dream is to find an unidentified or unknown market and develop it. Pharmaceutical companies could not be expected to act solely in the interest of public health. They are no more in the business of educating the public than a beer company is in the business of educating people about alcoholism

2. Pharmaceutical campaigns serve an education purpose for doctors and inform people who previously do not know they are suffering from the disorder, spurring many to seek needed help. Would somebody who is not having problems take a medicine that is costly and has side effects? I don't think too many people would do that. The idea that this is cosmetic psychopharmacology I find offensive


[JOIN] a group of volunteers working collaboratively on developing innovative solutions to this problem. The team's solution(s) will be published here.
1 0
Vote UpVote Down

Known Solutions

for Excessive influence of pharmaceutical manufacturers over doctors




Innovative Solutions

for Excessive influence of pharmaceutical manufacturers over doctors



Stop lectures touting drugs--lectures given by doctors on drug company payrolls.

One solution is to put an end to “Symposia”. These events occur at national meetings of major medical organizations. These symposia are held typically before or after the day’s formal activities...

Comments

on Excessive influence of pharmaceutical manufacturers over doctors

Post Comment
Perhaps the old time 'house visit' doctor cured more diseases with his "natural' medications. Even in biblical times, wounds were treated with wine and cheese mould. Antibiotics. If the pharmacutical...
- Max Friedenthal

[READ ALL COMMENTS]

Notify me of New Entries on this Page

Receive an email whenever a new solution or comment is added to this problem.
You can unsubscribe at any time.
Enter your Email:

Become a Problem Solver

Help solve problems for pay or for the Common Good. Use your expertise to help companies solve problems and get paid for every accepted solution. Or volunteer to work on solving problems for the Common Good. [REGISTER]

Volunteer to be a Moderator

If you are a regular contributor and are passionate about one or more topics, IdeaConnection is interested in talking to you about becoming a moderator. Please [REGISTER] as a member and [EMAIL US] your interest.

Solution Seekers: Risk-Free Problem Solving

IdeaConnection.com has thousands of expert, experienced Problem Solvers who can work collaboratively on new and innovative solutions to this problem. Risk-free: you pay only for satisfactory results. Hire a [TEAM OF EXPERTS]



Become a
Paid Problem Solver

Sign up for
our free weekly
Innovation Newsletter

© 2007-2012 IdeaConnection Ltd. All rights reserved.